VHF+ Contesting...
What is contesting?
Amateur Radio contesting is simply a predetermined period of time set aside by a contest sponsor during
which Amateur Radio operators (hams) are challenged to make as many two-way contacts as possible. This
"predetermined period of time" is called a "contest" because it is a competition amongst hams. The
definition of "two-way contacts" is described in the rules for each contest. Rules vary from sponsor
to sponsor; most can be found by searching on the internet.
The biggest U.S. sponsor of VHF+ contests each year is the American Radio Relay League (ARRL).
Details and rules for ARRL contests can be found on their
web site - there are many other contest sponsors as well, for example
the Spring Sprints, sponsored by the East Tennessee
DX Association and the Fall Sprints, sponsored by the
Southeast VHF Society. This is not an exhaustive list, but includes
two radically different approaches to contesting. The ARRL VHF+ contests are generally scheduled for
33 continuous hours on specific weekends using all VHF+ bands available, while the spring and fall
sprints are generally scheduled for four hours on various evenings using only one band per sprint.
VHF+ contacts and grid "squares"
Most, if not all, VHF+ contests define a "two-way contact" as a successful exchange of information
between stations located in different maidenhead grid squares. A maidenhead grid square was defined
as the area within a 1 degree latitude by 2 degrees longitude by European VHF managers at a meeting
in Maidenhead, England in 1980. Grid "squares" are not really square anywhere in the Continental
United States (CONUS). The 2 degree East-West "width" varies from approximately 124 miles in South
Texas to about 91 miles at the Canadian border. The one degree North-South "height" is approximately
69 miles, so you can see a grid "square" is really a grid "rectangle", but they are still called
"grid squares". Each grid is designated by a 4-digit indicator, two letters followed by two numbers.
For example, San Antonio, TX is in grid EL09. A very nice map showing all grid squares for the USA
is available in "pdf" format from
ICOM.
Some contests, specifically designed for 902 MHZ and above (microwaves), define a two-way contact as being
between different SUBgrids. Each 4-digit, 1 degree in latitude X 2 degrees in longitude, maidenhead grid
division is divided into 24 X 24 = 576 6-digit subgrids, each 2.5 minutes "high" by 5 minutes "wide". The
indicator for subgrids adds two letters to the 4-digit GRID designator. For example, the suburb of Leon
Valley on the NW corner of San Antonio is in EL09ql. Full details of the maidenhead grid system and the subgrids
can be found on the VHF South website.
Contesting
The 1981 ARRL Radio Amateur's Handbook devoted several column-inches to "contesting" on page 22-9. Quoting
the 1981Handbook:
"Contesting is to Amateur Radio what the Olympic Games are to worldwide amateur athletic competition: a
showcase to display talent and learned skills, as well as a stimulus for further achievement through
competition. Increased operating skills and greater station efficiency are the predominant end results
of Amateur Radio contesting, whether the operator is a serious contender or a casual participant."
To put this in perspective, I compared this statement with what my elmer told me "Back in the Day" (1961)
when I was first licensed as a Technician Class ham. He had said contests were the means to polish one's
operating techniques, test one's ham station, exercise its capabilities, and learn about propagation.
"Propagation" is how radio signals travel from a transmitter to a receiver. On VHF+ it is normally
limited to several hundred miles under the best of "normal" conditions. There are, however, occasional
"band openings" which make contacts over thousands of miles possible. Band openings are quite exciting
when they occur. In fact, learning about "normal" propagation and the various types of "special"
propagation which make openings possible can be entertaining in its own right!
To summarize, then, we participate in contests for the competition, to improve our operator skills,
to improve station capability and just for fun. It might be appropriate to say that it is the aspect
of competition which drives us to make improvements in skill and station; fun, then, might be
the natural result of performing at a higher level during competition! Whateverthecase, the natural
result of all this improvement of one's capability and VHF+ station brings us to another excerpt from
page 22-9 of the 1981 ARRL Radio Amateur's Handbook:
"The contest operator is also likely to have one of the better signals on the band – not necessarily
the most elaborate station equipment, but a signal enhanced by the most efficient use of station
components available. Contest operation encourages optimization of station and operator efficiency."
Amateur Radio frequency allocations
Our participation in VHF+ contests can also have benefit beyond those personal aspects described above;
sometimes mentioned with respect to contesting is that when participants submit their logs to ARRL,
information developed from analysis of logs gives our one, national-level Amateur Radio organization
means to prove that we ARE using our frequency allocations. Our frequency assignments are under
ongoing attack by commercial interests which see the possibility of making money by manufacturing
and distributing devices which use radio energy in some way. This problem is not limited to cell
phone interests; the "WiFi" computer craze is another example. the fact is that the frequencies
allocated to Amateur Radio use are vulnerable.
Amateur Radio lost 220 – 222 MHz a few years ago when the FCC reallocated this two megahertz of
bandwidth to a commercial enterprise (UPS - "Brown") which intended to place a communication system
tailored to support of their company operations there. After all is said and done, the attempted
commercial use never materialized; this bandwidth was ultimately not used and is now unused. We
have not, however, been able to regain the authorization to use 220-222MHz; once lost, our frequencies
are apparently gone forever, so protection of what we have is paramount. It is hoped that data
gleaned from contest logs CAN be used to somehow mitigate the attacks and preserve the bands we now
have!
Rover stations:
An aspect of VHF+ contesting which is unique to VHF+ is "rover" stations. As stated previously, VHF+
is normally limited in coverage, in contrast to the worldwide nature of HF (shortwave) propagation,
and contacts are defined by relatively small geographical areas (maidenhead grid squares) rather than
zones, countries or continents. Stations which can move amongst several of these grid squares,
termed "rovers", can provide myriad contacts for
both fixed stations and other rovers from grid squares which would otherwise have no VHF+ stations
operating within them. This is in contrast to portable stations which is operate from a fixed
location other than "home" but stay in one location for the entire contest. Rovers are, basically,
mobile stations.
Rovers must cover as much ground as possible, dashing from one hilltop to another in a series of
portable operations (shoot 'n' scoot mode - erecting antennas, operating, packing up, moving again),
or dashing through as many individual grid squares as possible operating mobile-in-motion (run 'n'
gun mode), all the while working to make and log contacts. Each mode of roving has its own
operational challenges. These are created by terrain, the presence of trees and other RF-absorbing
vegetation, weather, roads and road conditions, how many other hams are operational within normal
propagation range, and the like. Both could be said to be excellent practice for emergency
communications. Just ask the hams who took their mobile stations into the areas savaged by
hurricanes Katrina and Rita on the Gulf coast during the 2005 hurricane season; they went
specifically to augment, and in some cases temporarily replace, communication systems either
damaged or destroyed by these two massive storms.
For rovers, there are challenges created by the custom nature of installing equipment in vehicles
and the personal preferences involved in mobile operations. If one were to gather 500 (pick any
number) rovers in one location, there would be no two exactly alike. The top of the rover heap
is represented by a station which covers 10 or more bands (50MHz through 24GHz, for example), with
power limited only by what the state of the art technology can manage for whatever power source is
available (shoot 'n' scoot rovers can use generators at each portable location - mobile-in-motion
stations use automotive electrical system components), and the biggest antennas practical for the
roving mode employed (shoot 'n' scoot rovers erect towers with high-gain antennas at each portable
location, while the run 'n' gun rover is constrained to less than optimal antennas by the parameters
of roads, bridges, traffic, etc.). At the other end of the rover spectrum, an effective station
might be as simple as a single multi-band, multi-mode radio plugged into the cigarette lighter
connected to a couple of magnet-mount antennas slapped onto the roof of the car! It's VERY much
a matter of "You pays yer money and you takes yer choice."
Who participates?
Another quote from page 22-9 of the 1981 ARRL Radio Amateur's Handbook partially addresses this question:
"The ARRL contest program is so diverse that it holds appeal for almost every operator – the beginning
contester and the old hand, the newest Novice and oldest Extra-Classer, "Top Band" buff and microwave
enthusiast."
In other words, ANY LICENSED AMATEUR RADIO OPERATOR can participate! The variation in size, shape and
capability of stations participating in contests, however, is extraordinary. At the top of the pile
is the multi-operator station with full legal limit output on all bands, separate tall towers with
"large" antennas for each band, a separate operating position for each band, with top of the line
radios at each position. At the other end of the spectrum is the ham with a single multi-band,
multi-mode radio and one or more dipole antennas in the attic. Rover stations also exhibit a huge
range, as noted above.
Each ham participates with different goals in mind. The "top of the pile" stations might be serious
contenders going for top national or division scores, while the smaller stations described might be
simply trying to make a higher score than the last contest they entered or, just as simply, enjoying
the higher-than-normal activity levels present during contests. Some, knowing there are no VHF+
stations in a given maidenhead grid square get a kick out of traveling to said grid and providing
contacts for other stations which would have otherwise not been able to make a contact with that
grid! Just as the range of stations goes from all-inclusive to super-simple, based on the individual
drive and resources of a given HAM, the range of reasons to contest is also very wide and wholly a
matter of individual goals and perspectives. At the risk of being TOO general, it can be said that,
like almost ANY aspect of Amateur Radio, everything boils down to a matter of personal preference and
resources. Here, again, "You pays yer money and you takes yer choice!"
The role of population distribution
The map below, in which each dot represents 30,000 people, shows the population distribution as of 2003
in CONUS. By looking at this map, it should be clear that a Radio Amateur operator living in southern
New England is surrounded by a much higher population density and, therefore, many more hams than a
Radio Amateur living in central Nebraska. Obviously, there are far more hams in New England than in
central Nebraska!
Additionally, one ham might live in a valley, while another lives on a mountaintop. Whereas the opening
paragraph quoting the 1981 Radio Amateur's Handbook talked about Olympic competition, this can be
misleading. The Olympics are as close to a level playing field as there is; the track is the same for
all runners, the shotput weighs the same for all competitors, and the examples could go on and on.
Amateur Radio competition is different: There is no such thing as a "level playing field" in Amateur
Radio contesting. This could only be achieved if all hams had identical stations surrounded by the
same population density. This is not possible. In September, 2000, ND2X/R activated 35 grids, an
all-time record. The ND2X/R score was third in the nation, with the winner amassing almost three times
the ND2X/R score while activating only 13 grids. Can you guess where the winner operated? Yes, it
WAS in the northeast quadrant of CONUS. ND2X is not upset by not winning. ND2X is thrilled to have
set a record for number of grids activated! Different strokes for different folks! ND2X/R paid his
money and took his choice. You can, too! Come join the fun!